Sunday, October 1, 2017

Moscow. The view from my window


After last summer's amazing visit to Saint Petersburg (SPB), I was excited and intrigued to see Moscow. While I was overwhelmed by Moscow largeness, I felt that the difference between these two capitals (new Moscow and old SPB) have never been more striking. The root of these differences is, of course, the history of Russia. SPG was created and built by Peter the Great in early 1700s, as a window to Europe, to force a country isolated by Orthodox Christianity to join Europe’s road to Enlightenment. Meanwhile, Moscow which is almost 900 years old was and is now one of the pillars of Christian Orthodox tradition.



That tradition was rudely interrupted by October Revolution (1917) and communist aggressive anti-religious policies. After October Revolution Moscow lost a large number of its beautiful churches and Russians lost a significant part of their cultural identity. We rented an apartment in the heart of Moscow in an old apartment building, walking distance from Red Square. As we walked around the building I noticed a recently installed plaque on the building: The apartment building was built on the site of the church which was built 1686 and destroyed in 1929


The large old apartment in the heart of Moscow had many windows, with beautiful views and stories to tell.
Looking East is a beautiful grand cathedral looking brand new


The Cathedral of Christ the Savior is the second church constructed on the site. The first one was built in the 19th century to commemorate the heroes and victory in the First Patriotic War (Napoleon’s invasion in Russia). That Church was destroyed by Stalinist regime in the 1930’s. An Olympic size swimming pool was built on the site in 1960’s. The idea to rebuild the church was one of the first post-Soviet projects and mostly was executed on charitable donation of Russian citizens and ex-pats.

Looking North-West springs an ultra modern island of skyscrapers


Moscow-city or the Moscow Business Center complex is another baby of post-Soviet era grand projects and obviously a symbol of new Moscow global ambitions, this time looking in the future. The ambitions are on-going and ignore current political bickering. The beatification and modernization of Moscow is a project of surreal proportion.

The work is on-going 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The new sidewalks are paved with thick granite tiles, replacing the old asphalt sidewalks over large areas in the city center, with dozens of people working on each site. It is difficult to imagine the cost of this project, but it definitely provides a lot of working class jobs.


And looking directly North is Moscow of my youth


The glorious 70th. These New Arbat buildings looked magnificent to me when I was 18 years old; I had never seen modern buildings looking so big and grand. It was also a clever design idea to shape these buildings like open books. Obviously, the grandeur and magnificence didn’t last as with most construction of this period. These buildings are signs of the time and they are going through renovation efforts to make the best of it. The damage is particularly depressing when you see the Old Arbat neighborhood and imagine what streets were demolished to build the highway and these modern cheap monstrosities.




Wherever I go, I always check out food markets. Maybe it is my childhood memories when food was scarce or maybe just because I love good food. The state of the Danilovsky Market was exceptional in all departments







In addition to amazing food stands, the market was surrounded by eateries with amazing looks and smells. Every cuisine was represented: Georgian, Uzbek, Chinese, Thai and Vietnamese. At 11:00 am there was already a line to the Pho stand. We bought Uzbek samsa, which were still hot and Patrick finally tried real Russian kvas. This ancient, lightly fermented drink is impossible to understand when you buy it in the United States in plastic bottles. The real drink is slightly bubbly, has lovely flavor and is very refreshing.

To get to the market we took the metro to station Polyanka (meadow).
If you want to know how a perfect metro system should work, you must visit Moscow and use the metro. A weekly pass for all public transportation is less than $14. If you are in the middle of the train and exit to the platform, by the time you get to the end of station platform the next train has arrived. You are connected to free Wi-Fi at all times. It was a consistent experience throughout entire week. The only time we had to wait for about 3 min was after 11 pm. The metro first open in mid 1930’s and became a signature Moscow project. It was built to last and works like I never seen in any other metropolis. All stations have different design and older stations have imposing Soviet imagery, while modern stations looking very slick.






Nothing helps more to appreciate the country or a city than having enlightened friends which know the place well and who are generous enough to share their knowledge with you. My old friends took us to several lovely excursions, including ancient city of Vladimir. It was the taste of Russia outside Moscow - old, vast, beautiful and spiritual in traditional religious way.





The amazing tour of Moscow hidden treasures with old churches with fascinating history of survival communist regime, the streets of Old Arbat with many beautiful mansions left from the pre-revolutionary times when the area was populated by wealthy merchants and old nobility, the historical mansion, which was described in War and Peace as Rostov’s family home
The cloister setup by Elizaveta Fedorovna, member of Tzar’s family with tragic personal story of sacrifice and devotion. The church of remarkable beauty designed and built according to her vision behind the gate of the cloister.
There is more to Moscow than Kremlin!

Soviet imagery is very important and imposing theme in Moscow.





These days in SPB you can hardly notice remains of the Soviet regime. Most of the signs are gone and because the city is a complete architectural ensemble, there are no sign of Soviet architecture in the center of SPB. In Moscow, Soviet past plays a strange trick on you. Most of the Soviet imaginary has nostalgic appeal and sometimes kitschy expression. The explanations which were given to me by Russians, emphasized that keeping this imaginary – is preserving history. By design or subconsciously it felt more like whitewashing than preserving a history. Without the menace and depravity which associated with these images it didn’t feel like history, but more like a cute nostalgic movie about the past. If Russians decisionmakers really cared about history there should be a history museum where these artifacts are accompanied by appropriated context. Some of the imaginary was an all-out lie: the plaque installed on the Kremlin wall in 2015 to commemorate WWII depicts imaginary battle for Kremlin




There was also a different character to public events. In SPB, as part of annual White Nights festival, the live classical music was performed in city parks and it was in perfect harmony with classical city architecture. Moscow too was filled with music, but of another kind. On the Red Square nightly fireworks marked a week-long parade of military orchestras.
While Moscow Central park (Park Gor’kogo) was immaculately taken care off, when we visited, the loudspeaker projected live bad performance of the worst sample of Soviet pop-music. That was obnoxious and disturbing.

Obviously not everything could or should be moved to museum. The most impressive site of Soviet period is VDNH (pronounce ve-de-en-ha) stands for Exhibition of achievements of industry and agriculture. The site has plenty of Soviet imaginary and is the home of the most stunning sculpture of Soviet period created by Vera Muchina - Worker and Kolkhoz Woman




How to sum it up? What about the food, museums, theater, restaurants, pelmeni?





It is impossible to tell it all. The experience leaves the visitor overwhelmed with the feeling that to know Moscow will take many more visits and loving Moscow may take a lifetime. Just ten days visit cannot cover the largeness, history, the speed of changes and layers of complexity and culture. As Russians will say -- Moscow is a city of contrasts.
On the last day, after few days of miserable cold rain and grey skies, the weather suddenly turned sunny and warm. I told the driver who was taking us to airport how sad I was to leave the city on such a beautiful day. He said: “don’t worry, it’s not going to last.” So long Moscow!


3 comments:

  1. "Славные 70-е" - да и 80-е тоже ничего! Скамейка у театра на Таганке...
    14 долларов проездной - это, конечно, шок для американца, но для масштаба надо бы привести средний доход минус осн. расходы.
    Спг - я бы переправил на спб.
    "...all-out lie: the plaque installed on the Kremlin wall in 2015 to comemorate WWII depicts imagenary battle for Kremlin" - ну почему ложь? Была битва за Москву, действит. на подступах к Кремлю. Правда, не все защитники были такие сытые и экипированные...
    Прочел недавно Владимова "Генерал и его армия".
    Аффтар, пешы исчо!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, very good, and you think of yourself as a visitor in your hometown, assuming Moscow was your starting point. I understand the frustration over the Soviet symbol and rewriting history. My hometown of Richmond, VA, USA, has gone through a major transformation. It is considered a foodie destination and a modern art center. Yet, the place is still dripping in Confederate symbols and museums. People I grew up with are not willing to give the symbols of their youth or to accept that much of the history they cherish is racist, and it is offensive to so many others. The trick is to figure out what to keep and what to toss. However, the Old Testament warned about this in the Top 10, no less: Thou shalt not worship graven images. It is amazing that old truth tells us to accept progress.
    Please write more about the contract between Moscow when you were young and now.

    ReplyDelete
  3. По поводу того, что в Москве каждый год перекладывают плитку, что бы полностью "освоить" бюджет, прекрасное у Лесного https://nl.livejournal.com/1403119.html#/1403119.html:

    С каждым годом тихие смиренные монахи в ритуальных оранжевых одеяниях, раз за разом перекладывающие плитку на Тверской только затем, чтобы через пару месяцев начать свою кажущуюся со стороны бессмысленной работу заново, вызывают у меня все больше уважения и понимания.

    С раннего утра и до позднего вечера, а потом с позднего вечера и до раннего утра они, подобно трудолюбивым муравьям, усердно выкладывают из гранита, мрамора, асфальта, щебня и бордюрного камня гигантскую мандалу, описывающую устройство нашего мира: круг внутри Третьего транспортного кольца - это измерение божеств, бодхисаттв и будд; за Третьим транспортным кольцом - Вселенная; а гранит, мрамор, асфальт, щебень и бордюрный камень символизируют единство пяти мудростей как аспектов духовного Пробуждения.

    Через два месяца ветер, дождь и сами немного напоминающие таджиков оранжевые монахи аккуратно и безжалостно разрушают выложенное из плитки изображение мира спасения, и все повторяется.

    И ты смотришь на этот божественный пиздец, смотришь на гранит, смотришь на щебень, смотришь на бело-зеленые заграждения (где белый цвет соответствует Акшобхье, а зеленый - Амогхасиддхе) и понимаешь, что пока ты, Лесной, конечно, не достиг его уровня, но сострадание уже подступило к горлу, и просветление уже не за горами, и дорогу осилит идущий, а самая длинная дорога в чистую землю будд всегда начинается с первого бордюрного камня.

    ReplyDelete